NewsToon, an app for iPhone and iTouch created by Pulitzer Prize winner
Mark Fiore and featuring some of his best political cartoons, has been cleared for sale on iTunes - after previously being rejected for ridiculing public figures.
Apple CEO Steve Jobs himself reportedly called the rejection a mistake in an e-mail response to several customers.
Fiore, who is the first online-only cartoonist to win a
Pulitzer, a prestigious US award for achievements in newspaper journalism, literature and musical composition, for work that ran on the
SFGate.com web site, reported that his app was rejected by Apple in December because it included cartoons that ridiculed public figures.
The New York Times points out that cartoons can apparently violate Apple’s license agreement with developers, which states that apps may be rejected if the content “may be found objectionable, for example, materials that may be considered obscene, pornographic, or defamatory.”
After winning the Pulitzer prize for editorial cartooning last Monday and
telling the Nieman Journalism Lab of his app’s rejection the next day, Mr. Fiore was encouraged by Apple to submit it again.
Apple chief executive Steve Jobs told a customer, Robert Williamson, who asked about Mark Fiore’s rejected app that the rejection "was a mistake that’s being fixed”.
Mr. Williamson forwarded the message to
The New York Times after he
mentioned it in a comment on an NYT blog post.
"Fiore’s app will be in the store shortly," Jobs told another Apple customer (see
TechCrunch). "That was a mistake."
The app offers an automatically-updating collection of bite-sized satire, from Fiore, who happily talks up the controversy
in his sales pitch for the iApp. "Political cartoons have never been this funny, accessible and revealing!" he enthuses.
When his NewsToons app, which displays his weekly animated cartoons, was developed, Mr. Fiore said he had not heard of “the whole concept of getting rejected for ridiculing public figures.”
“That’s what I do. That’s my life!” he commented. “That’s a tough one to get around if you’re a political cartoonist.”
After NewsToons was turned down in mid-December, the NYT reports Mr. Fiore, who uses Apple products to create his cartoons, did not try to submit it again, “mainly because it seemed like it would be so daunting.
“It’s not like I had a phone number for someone at Apple,” he said, adding, “interestingly enough, I do now.”
While this is good news for Fiore, there must be concern from other political cartoonists that haven't won Pullitzers that their work may not be permitted on iPhone or iPad apps because of the anonymous censorship of some iTunes gatekeeper. Apple has previously rejected comics apps on content grounds, as we have previously reported.
• More about Mark Fiore's NewsToon App
• Mark Fiore's official web site: www.markfiore.com